Feedback. We know it’s important, we know it’s needed; but when it’s not positive, we don’t want to give it and we certainly don’t want to receive it.
Years ago, I heard the phrase “Feedback is a gift”. It was during a time in my teaching career where teachers in my school were taking it upon themselves to visit each other in the classroom and observe each other’s practice – to learn from each other and to give each other feedback.
We all loved getting the compliments and the positive comments.
The negative ones?
Not so much.
But that was where the learning was and where the most value was – someone has taken the time to be honest. It’s uncomfortable for everyone, and it’s easier not to do it. If someone is taking the initiative to give me “negative feedback”, for my own benefit, I should respect that and listen up.
As teachers we need to be open to feedback – we are getting it every day! From students, parents, colleagues, inspectors or mentors. By being open, it doesn’t mean that we automatically agree – it means that we will listen and consider it.
Here are some pointers for managing negative feedback.
1. Mindset
We need to rephrase the negative feedback as “constructive feedback”.
Because that is what it is, or what it should be – constructive.
None of us are perfect.
This type of feedback should highlight something that you may not be aware of and by making you aware will help you in doing the best job that you can.
This is a positive thing.
2. Stay Calm
Depending on the tone of communication, body language, personality and relationship you have with the person giving you feedback, it might be difficult to get past the emotions you are feeling and your perception of how it is being communicated to you.
Stay calm.
Take a breath.
Listen to what is being said as rationally as you can.
If you feel like this is something you cannot do, you should re-arrange another time to continue the conversation when you are calm.
3. Take Notes
Write down what the problem is and what solutions or strategies the person is suggesting to you.
This will focus the conversation and allow you to recap at the end of the discussion and reflect at a later stage.
This will also help you to focus if you are feeling emotionally charged at what is being said.
4. Ask Questions
Find out exactly what the person wants or needs from you.
Depending on what the issue is, this can often be some small adjustment.
Whatever the issue is, it is vital that you are crystal clear on what steps you need to take to fix it.
If the feedback is constructive, the person should be able to answer your questions and make suggestions for improvement.
5. Honesty
Communicate with the person how you feel about what he or she is saying. If you disagree, share this in a calm manner. Open up the conversation so you can have dialogue around what has been said.
If you agree, share this too and let the person know how they might best support you if you are struggling.
6. Be Grateful
Nobody likes having difficult conversations – it is extremely uncomfortable for most of us and we will avoid these situations as much as possible. Whatever your thoughts are about what has been said, this person has taken the initiative to address an issue they think is important enough to be said.
They care.
It’s a win-win.
As upsetting as a conversation like this may (or may not) be, we should try to be grateful when people give us the gift of feedback.
We hope this article was helpful.
Top 5 Tech Tips for a More Inclusive Classroom
Creating an inclusive classroom is all about making sure every student feels supported, engaged, and confident in their learning. Luckily, technology can make this so much easier! Whether you’re a tech whiz or just starting out, here are five simple (but super effective) ways to use digital tools to make learning more accessible for everyone.
Subbing in Ireland – Top 10 Tips
Subbing in Ireland is a great way to gain experience while keeping your work life flexible. Follow these tips, and you’ll set yourself up for success.
Ready to dive in? Get your paperwork sorted, put yourself out there, and enjoy the journey. Happy teaching!
€49 EPV Summer Courses for Teachers
Our EPV Special Offer!
Course groups fill up quickly as we have limited capacity.
Please book your place ASAP to avoid disappointment!
EPV Summer Courses 2025
Here is a brief update of our summer course plans for 2025.
We will have a few new courses to add to the collection so watch this space!
The Not-So-Secret Diary of Dr Katriona O Sullivan
I am Dr. Katriona O’Sullivan, a resilient memoirist and psychologist, who has defied poverty, addiction, and homelessness to earn a PhD from Trinity College Dublin and be an amazing academic working in in Maynooth University. My debut book, “Poor” chronicles my journey from hardship to hope.
Teachers for Gaza
What we can go to help with what is happening in Gaza.
